Advertisement
PregnancyNewbornInfantToddlerPreschoolerSchool AgeHealth & Medical
November 22, 2009 SEARCH drSpock 
Ask Our ExpertsMessage BoardsToolsConsumer AlertsTelevisionBooksA-Z Topics
DrSpock.com

 Family & Issues | Discipline
BACK TO: Discipline |
  PREVIOUS MESSAGENEXT MESSAGE  
AUTHOR: bozorqDATE: 07/18/03 5:37pm
SUBJECT: Re: Should I Spank?
IN REPLY TO: Should I Spank?
AUTHOR: Mom56701
No you shouldn't do anything until sit down with a pen and paper and determine where the real problems lie. You need a plan. Stop parenting by the seat of your pants.

Problem #1 Never threaten to punish a child and then not follow through. Simply put, that makes you a liar. How can she believe anything you say if you don't keep your word?

Problem #2 Your child is desperatley crying out for boundaries and you are not taking the appropriate steps to teach her boundaries.

How to set boundaries.

Let's start with Boundary #1
You will respect your parents.

- Define the problem: Talking back, cursing and throwing things are all disrespectful acts.

- Determine the appropriate consequences.

I have 13 year old daughter... here's some consequences that are very effective:
1) Cleaning the bathroom.
2) Cleaning the kitchen floor on her hands and knees with only a mop bucket of soapy water and a sponge.
3) Taking away her: Gameboy, computer time, or boom box.
4) Refusing to take her to anime night at the library.
5) All of the above!

Remember the consequence must be severe enough that she will not want to experience it often.

- You must communicate to your daughter during a teachable moment, the rules of your house and the consequences for breaking those rules.

- I guarantee your child will soon act out to see if you mean what you say. This is your child trying to grow and this is your opportunity to help her.

When your child back talks you handle it like this:
1) Remain calm and confident.

2) Inform your child, that because she choose to act inappropriatly she will suffer the consequence.

3) Invoke the consequence. (Don't WIMP OUT!!! don't let tears, emotions or insults change this outcome. In fact, the more your child brings it on, the more you set your jaw.) Your child must learn that inappropriate action leads to suffering.

4) As she experiences the consequence empathize with her. "I feel hurt, daughter, when you speak to me that way. And I feel for you because you will not have your gameboy for the next two weeks."

5) Remain consistent. Stick to the plan.

Life works on reality consequences. Getting angry, sending guilt messages, nagging or withdrawing love usually do not motivate people to change. True change usually comes only when someone’s behavior causes him to encounter reality consequences, such as pain or loss of time, money, possessions or other things she enjoys.

I strongly suggest the following book.
http://www.family.org/resources/itempg.cfm?itemid=2844
MESSAGES
Should I Spank?
Mom5670105/18/03 06:50am
Re: Should I Spank?
Mom5670105/18/03 03:52pm
Re: Should I Spank?
jayne_05/19/03 03:17am
      Re: Should I Spank?
Paulamom05/19/03 03:19pm
         Re: Should I Spank?
jayne_05/20/03 05:17am
Re: Should I Spank?
Paul_Scott05/18/03 07:44pm
Re: Should I Spank?
feetslaps06/16/03 04:36pm
      Re: Should I Spank?
luvmybabes07/08/03 04:59pm
         Re: Should I Spank?
jayrb07/09/03 06:00am
            Re: Should I Spank?
rennie_gade07/09/03 02:16pm
               Re: Should I Spank?
jayrb07/09/03 04:30pm
               Re: Should I Spank?
luvmybabes07/09/03 06:00pm
                  Re: Should I Spank?
luvmybabes07/20/03 07:06pm
      Re: Should I Spank?
jakey07/17/03 04:52am
      Re: Should I Spank?
1helluvaguy02/21/04 07:25pm
      Re: Should I Spank?
1helluvaguy02/21/04 07:25pm
Re: Should I Spank?
angel girl07/07/03 08:04pm
Re: Should I Spank?
dadthespanker07/10/03 07:36pm
      Re: Should I Spank?
eleeandbjmommy07/11/03 09:18pm
Re: Should I Spank?
maggiemoore07/13/03 07:34pm
Re: Should I Spank?
bozorq07/18/03 05:37pm
      Re: Should I Spank?
saxman07/27/03 11:42pm
Re: Should I Spank?
saxman07/25/03 03:38am
Re: Should I Spank?
saxman08/01/03 12:55am
Re: Should I Spank?
jayrb09/24/03 05:53am
  PREVIOUS DISCUSSIONNEXT DISCUSSION  
OUR ADVERTISERS



OUR ADVERTISERS

About Us | Contact Us | Our Partners
Privacy Policy | Ethics | Advertising Policy | Terms of Service

© Copyright 2004 The Dr. Spock Company. All Rights Reserved.

THIS SITE DOES NOT PROVIDE MEDICAL ADVICE. The information drSpock.com provides is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your health care professional if you have a specific health concern. Mention or advertisement of any product, service, or brand does not constitute endorsement, guarantee, or recommendation by The Dr. Spock Company. Please read our full Terms of Service.