Advertisement
PregnancyNewbornInfantToddlerPreschoolerSchool AgeHealth & Medical
November 08, 2009 SEARCH drSpock 
Ask Our ExpertsMessage BoardsToolsConsumer AlertsTelevisionBooksA-Z Topics
DrSpock.com

 Family & Issues | Discipline
BACK TO: Discipline |
  PREVIOUS MESSAGENEXT MESSAGE  
AUTHOR: rennie_gadeDATE: 05/23/03 8:10pm
SUBJECT: Re: Teenage spanking problems
IN REPLY TO: Re: Teenage spanking problems
AUTHOR: BrianP
Brian, I don't know that anything other than the overdue spanking of an incorrigible brat could have a parent "looking forward" to the job. It sounds as if your older step-daughter is pushing the tolerance envelope to see just how much contrariness she's going to be permitted. And if the preferred method of reacquainting her with the chain of command in the family unit has been to redden her bare bottom in over-the-knee fashion, I don't see how it can do her any harm to be made fully aware of your instructive/corrective abilities as the paternal authority figure in her life.

Classof68 suggested having her mother sit in on any such spanking. I think that's something the two of you could sort out between yourselves. Without knowing the tenor of your relationship with the girl in question, I can't confidently come down on one side or the other of that discussion.

As for your son being too much of a young man now to be put over your knee, the alternative is to keep ratcheting up the intensity of his punishments, is it not? That's heading into dangerous territory. I think you're mistaken if you regard the "childish" associations with over-the-knee spanking as a detriment in the attempt to adjust an adolescent attitude.

You're not obligated to observe the Marquis of Queensbury rules in spanking your son. Getting his bottom smacked isn't supposed to be a rite of passage. If his behaviour calls for a spanking, why should you feel any compunction to somehow change the traditional methodology in order to accommodate his I'm-too-old-to-be-spanked-like-a-child illusions? If he found it sufficiently upsetting to be once again put over your knee for his bottom warmings, he might well expedite his emotional growth and development to keep pace with his body.

Spanking doesn't have to be complicated. If you've got a lap and two good arms, the rest of it has been pretty straightforward for umpteen generations. It sounds to me like your own daughter has certainly got it figured out. The world keeps turning in only one direction, and a spanking, when all is said and done, is still a spanking.
MESSAGES
Teenage spanking problems
BrianP05/19/03 03:25am
Re: Teenage spanking problems
classof6805/21/03 02:54am
      Re: Teenage spanking problems
BrianP05/23/03 05:30am
         Re: Teenage spanking problems
rennie_gade05/23/03 08:10pm
            Re: Teenage spanking problems
luvmybabes06/27/03 11:10am
               Re: Teenage spanking problems
eleeandbjmommy07/02/03 07:35pm
         Re: Teenage spanking problems
classof6805/29/03 02:15am
Re: Teenage spanking problems
janie_05/23/03 11:39pm
Re: Teenage spanking problems
Intelectual05/31/03 08:10pm
      Re: Teenage spanking problems
janie_06/01/03 12:09am
Re: Teenage spanking problems
brandy12305/31/03 02:42pm
Re: Teenage spanking problems
momof2ofeach05/31/03 07:36am
Re: Teenage spanking problems
Ckidz100105/31/03 11:39pm
      Re: Teenage spanking problems
LiaK06/03/03 04:02pm
Re: Teenage spanking problems
meshar06/01/03 12:14am
Re: Teenage spanking problems
rennie_gade06/04/03 11:28am
Re: Teenage spanking problems
bunytail06/06/03 07:55pm
Re: Teenage spanking problems
imachristian7806/06/03 04:58am
      Re: Teenage spanking problems
imachristian7806/24/03 04:54pm
         Re: Teenage spanking problems
BrianP06/27/03 04:20am
            Re: Teenage spanking problems
classof6807/02/03 07:50am
Re: Teenage spanking problems
kevin707/11/03 08:01am
Re: Teenage spanking problems
EmmaJD07/14/03 04:25am
      Re: Teenage spanking problems
jayrb07/14/03 01:02pm
         Re: Teenage spanking problems
EmmaJD07/18/03 05:17am
Re: Teenage spanking problems
Big-D07/31/03 02:44am
      Re: Teenage spanking problems
saxman07/31/03 10:30pm
Re: Teenage spanking problems
saxman07/28/03 10:59pm
Re: Teenage spanking problems
saxman07/31/03 12:57pm
  PREVIOUS DISCUSSIONNEXT DISCUSSION  
OUR ADVERTISERS



OUR ADVERTISERS

About Us | Contact Us | Our Partners
Privacy Policy | Ethics | Advertising Policy | Terms of Service

© Copyright 2004 The Dr. Spock Company. All Rights Reserved.

THIS SITE DOES NOT PROVIDE MEDICAL ADVICE. The information drSpock.com provides is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your health care professional if you have a specific health concern. Mention or advertisement of any product, service, or brand does not constitute endorsement, guarantee, or recommendation by The Dr. Spock Company. Please read our full Terms of Service.