Advertisement
PregnancyNewbornInfantToddlerPreschoolerSchool AgeHealth & Medical
March 22, 2010 SEARCH drSpock 
Ask Our ExpertsMessage BoardsToolsConsumer AlertsTelevisionBooksA-Z Topics
DrSpock.com

 Family & Issues | Discipline
BACK TO: Discipline |
  PREVIOUS MESSAGENEXT MESSAGE  
AUTHOR: nuperDATE: 06/12/02 4:47pm
SUBJECT: Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
IN REPLY TO: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
AUTHOR: QUITAS
Here is the one I would use for that specific example when my daughter was 5. I would tell her very clearly that the things she didn't put away were the things that I would know she no longer wanted. I would show her a big giant trash bag and tell her that if the room wasn't all picked up within a certain amount of time, I would come in and put everything that was not picked up in the bag and it would be put away for X number of days. When she was 5 it would only be for 2-3 days at the most- otherwise she would forget about the things. And she would scream and cry and beg for another chance while I was putting one thing after another into the bag. So for 2 days, she would go to get something that was put in the bag and then realize she lost it just because she chose not to put them away when she was asked to. And I would take EVERYTHING!!! Clothes, toys, games no matter how big or small- it was GONE! When I did give them back it was with the understanding that they would be put away, or they would be taken for another 2 days. It works especially well when a favorite toy or piece of clothing was in the bag. I'd just say, OH WELL, in 2 days when you get it back I'm sure you'll put it away when you're asked to. Do Not sneak anything out early!!!! Even if you want her to wear a cetain thing that has been stored, the whole things crumbles if you don't hold out and keep everything in the bag.
I did it for several years when she wouldn't get busy cleaning. It got to the point that all I had to do was walk past her room and shake the bag without even saying a word- she would jump back to work. She's 11 now and I haven't had to do it for at least 3 years. Her room still gets very messy, but now when I tell her to clean it- she does.
MESSAGES
WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
QUITAS06/11/02 04:08pm
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
lovingparent06/13/02 09:24pm
      Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
Zmom08/23/02 10:16am
         Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
saxman08/13/03 11:49pm
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
nuper06/12/02 04:47pm
      Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
saxman08/13/03 11:43pm
         Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
nuper08/14/03 09:58am
            Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
saxman08/15/03 09:50pm
               Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
nuper08/16/03 02:08pm
                  When she was a girl
saxman08/17/03 08:39pm
                     Re: When she was a girl
nuper08/18/03 09:23am
                        Re: When she was a girl
saxman08/18/03 03:29pm
                           Re: When she was a girl
nuper08/19/03 09:09am
                              A Good Foundation
saxman08/20/03 11:22pm
                                 Re: A Good Foundation
nuper08/30/03 01:14pm
                                    ACA
saxman08/30/03 09:52pm
                                       Re: ACA
nuper08/31/03 02:52am
                                          My words
saxman08/31/03 11:48am
         Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
greeneyes108/30/03 09:13pm
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
hotty06/22/02 04:38pm
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
velvet8307/11/02 06:45pm
      Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
eldyka07/12/02 09:39pm
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
stephbe08/07/02 04:43pm
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
MommyAngel08/19/02 08:01pm
      Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
saxman08/14/03 12:07am
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
Zmom08/23/02 10:08am
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
saxman08/12/03 09:22pm
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
saxman08/12/03 09:32pm
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
greeneyes108/30/03 09:30pm
Re: WHEN IS SPANKING NECESSARY
teacherkeith10/02/03 03:29pm
  PREVIOUS DISCUSSIONNEXT DISCUSSION  
OUR ADVERTISERS



OUR ADVERTISERS

About Us | Contact Us | Our Partners
Privacy Policy | Ethics | Advertising Policy | Terms of Service

© Copyright 2004 The Dr. Spock Company. All Rights Reserved.

THIS SITE DOES NOT PROVIDE MEDICAL ADVICE. The information drSpock.com provides is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your health care professional if you have a specific health concern. Mention or advertisement of any product, service, or brand does not constitute endorsement, guarantee, or recommendation by The Dr. Spock Company. Please read our full Terms of Service.