Advertisement
PregnancyNewbornInfantToddlerPreschoolerSchool AgeHealth & Medical
November 08, 2009 SEARCH drSpock 
Ask Our ExpertsMessage BoardsToolsConsumer AlertsTelevisionBooksA-Z Topics
DrSpock.com

 Toddler & Preschool | Toilet Training
BACK TO: Toilet Training |
  PREVIOUS MESSAGENEXT MESSAGE  
AUTHOR: sycamore631DATE: 06/10/02 6:56pm
SUBJECT: Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
IN REPLY TO: Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
AUTHOR: cizweb
Cizweb - First of all, a great big {{{HUG}}} for you. I'm so sorry for what you are having to go through with your son. I'm sure when he was first born you could never have imagined that toilet training him would be so hard.

It must be very difficult for you to receive unsolicited advice from people who think they know it all. Unfortunately, when any child is having problems, people always look at the parent and think they must be doing something wrong. People need to realize (and this is something I've had to realize about my daughter) that children are totally separate people from their parents. We can work with our children on many different skills, but sometimes our kids are going to do their own thing no matter how hard us parents try.

I posted on 6/2 and was one of the people who advised that kids should clean up after themselves. The rationale behind that was kids do not like being away from their playtime and would not like cleaning up their poop. However, some kids are "poop painters" (a term I heard from a friend of mine who worked for years in daycare) and actually enjoy playing with poop. If a child loves playing with poop, then cleaning up after themselves will probably backfire.

As for the child psychologist - I say go for it. My daughter was traumatized by an automatic flushing toilet and refused to use any toilet, including the one at home. She would only use little potty chairs. It took me 1 1/2 months for me to get her to use our potty, and it was an idea that I just stumbled on. However, she was still fighting us a little whenever we asked her to go potty. She didn't like using toilets away from home. I was beginning to see a bad power struggle between us, and I knew that if I didn't do something fast, this could be a long, drawn-out problem. My daughter's doctor was concerned because her regression had lasted over two months (toileting regression should not last more than 2 weeks to a month) and he recommended a counselor to her. After the counselor talked to her for an hour, it was like a switch was flipped in her head! She has stopped fighting with us, and has started to use toilets outside of the house (including some public toilets). Needless to say, we are ecstatic over her progress. If I ever have a potty problem with my daughter again, I will not hesitate for a second to take her back to this counselor.

I've learned that all it takes is one little thing to cause a huge setback. If there is anyone who has been following this post who thinks that potty problems could never happen with their child--think again! It can happen to any child.

Good luck to everyone who has been having problems. Please keep us posted on any progress.

MESSAGES
4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom03/08/02 08:12pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
Cosmo03/09/02 08:56am
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom03/09/02 04:05pm
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
old mom03/17/02 09:33pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
looking4answers09/04/02 09:17am
               Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom09/09/02 01:16pm
                  Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
looking4answers09/09/02 07:12pm
                     Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom09/12/02 01:01pm
                  Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
Mommy_ToGo02/03/03 06:22pm
                     Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
poopiepotty02/04/03 04:45pm
                        Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
Mommy_ToGo02/05/03 06:41am
                        Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
lisal02/24/03 10:22am
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
ryansmommy01/03/03 03:07pm
               Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
jamesmum01/08/03 11:42am
                  Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
ryansmommy01/10/03 01:30pm
                     Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
kiditis02/08/03 07:52pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
kiditis02/08/03 07:41pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
Contom05/15/02 07:13pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom05/15/02 10:20pm
NO poop - PERIOD - not in the diaper, not in the potty!!!!!
Lee.Lee05/16/02 04:57pm
      Re: NO poop - PERIOD - not in the diaper, not in the potty!!!!!
PAVLISCSAK05/16/02 05:41pm
         Re: NO poop - PERIOD - not in the diaper, not in the potty!!!!!
tbugsmom05/17/02 05:37pm
      Re: NO poop - PERIOD - not in the diaper, not in the potty!!!!!
tbugsmom05/17/02 05:33pm
      Re: NO poop - PERIOD - not in the diaper, not in the potty!!!!!
boysmom06/22/02 08:22am
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
catriles05/17/02 11:13am
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom05/17/02 05:40pm
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
catriles05/17/02 06:33pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom05/18/02 06:39am
               Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
catriles05/18/02 11:37am
               Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
catriles05/18/02 11:39am
                  Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
lsqueal05/22/02 07:50am
                     Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
cizweb06/02/02 03:52pm
                        Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/05/02 06:38pm
                           Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
damom06/10/02 10:33am
                              Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/15/02 08:59pm
                                 Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
damom06/16/02 10:22pm
                                    Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/17/02 11:45pm
                                       Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
damom06/22/02 08:48pm
                                       Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
hopin4progress10/22/02 12:05am
                                          Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom10/22/02 11:58am
                           Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
cizweb06/08/02 04:34pm
                              Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
sycamore63106/10/02 06:56pm
                                 Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/15/02 08:53pm
                                    Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
sycamore63106/17/02 06:04pm
                              Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/15/02 08:46pm
                     Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom05/31/02 05:47pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
mmsmom05/22/02 08:39pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom05/31/02 05:52pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
thumpersmom05/30/02 03:57pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
thumpersmom05/30/02 03:57pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
damom06/07/02 11:35am
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
3179806/01/02 11:01am
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/02/02 06:15pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
sycamore63106/02/02 05:56pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/05/02 06:25pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
thumpersmom06/04/02 06:09pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
neenees mom06/03/02 07:29pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/05/02 06:34pm
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
sabrina'smom06/09/02 12:23pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/15/02 08:34pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
zkmom06/11/02 07:21am
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
sabrina'smom06/11/02 08:15pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/15/02 08:27pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tiggerlilly7706/17/02 12:38am
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom06/17/02 11:50pm
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
damom08/18/02 06:46pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom08/18/02 07:09pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
native1796308/24/02 03:36pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
ohboy09/01/02 05:57pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
catwinsmom09/05/02 04:09pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom09/09/02 01:05pm
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
catwinsmom09/18/02 02:24pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom10/22/02 12:02pm
               Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
catwinsmom10/22/02 02:30pm
                  Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom10/22/02 06:32pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
mapila10/24/02 11:22am
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
catwinsmom10/25/02 03:45pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
outofideas10/25/02 04:49pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom10/28/02 07:26pm
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
outofideas10/29/02 06:48pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom10/31/02 10:31am
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
damom10/28/02 10:21am
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
outofideas10/28/02 03:47pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
SoCalMomof401/01/03 07:03pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
jmmommy01/03/03 12:32pm
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
SoCalMomof401/03/03 02:48pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
jmmommy01/06/03 07:18am
               Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
SoCalMomof401/06/03 10:18am
               Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom01/06/03 01:08pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom01/06/03 12:57pm
         Used a laxative today
SoCalMomof401/06/03 06:22pm
            Re: Used a laxative today
jmmommy01/09/03 06:07am
            Re: Used a laxative today
jmmommy01/14/03 06:13am
               Re: Used a laxative today
SoCalMomof401/14/03 08:49am
                  Re: Used a laxative today
jmmommy01/14/03 10:50am
            Re: Used a laxative today
krisf01/21/03 12:43pm
               Re: Used a laxative today
SoCalMomof401/21/03 03:59pm
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
SoCalMomof401/06/03 01:08pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
tbugsmom01/06/03 01:12pm
            Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
jmmommy01/07/03 06:26am
      She IS very young--
rachael200301/14/03 12:39pm
         Re: She IS very young--
SoCalMomof401/14/03 04:32pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
PAIGE B.01/06/03 04:16pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
mykidsmomtoo01/14/03 09:55pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
lnorris01/16/03 09:34am
For those with night wetting problems--
rachael200301/14/03 04:41pm
      Re: For those with night wetting problems--
mykidsmomtoo01/14/03 11:58pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
lnorris01/16/03 09:18am
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
maggiesmommy9801/28/03 10:36am
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
harley9li01/17/03 08:52am
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
jmmommy01/20/03 05:17am
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
mnbvc01/24/03 06:07pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
Trevs Mom01/25/03 01:44pm
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
jmmommy01/27/03 06:38am
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
wannabeagoodmom02/10/03 10:27am
         Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
wannabeagoodmom02/10/03 10:38am
      Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
lnorris02/20/03 09:34am
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
kellie002302/03/03 08:35pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
KARENRENE02/22/03 08:42pm
Re: 4 year old refuses to poop in potty HELP!!!
mom2paige02/24/03 07:38pm
  PREVIOUS DISCUSSIONNEXT DISCUSSION  
OUR ADVERTISERS



OUR ADVERTISERS

About Us | Contact Us | Our Partners
Privacy Policy | Ethics | Advertising Policy | Terms of Service

© Copyright 2004 The Dr. Spock Company. All Rights Reserved.

THIS SITE DOES NOT PROVIDE MEDICAL ADVICE. The information drSpock.com provides is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your health care professional if you have a specific health concern. Mention or advertisement of any product, service, or brand does not constitute endorsement, guarantee, or recommendation by The Dr. Spock Company. Please read our full Terms of Service.