PregnancyNewbornInfantToddlerPreschoolerSchool AgeHealth & Medical
September 07, 2008 SEARCH drSpock 
Ask Our ExpertsMessage BoardsToolsConsumer AlertsTelevisionBooksA-Z Topics
DrSpock.com

HOT TOPICS
*Pregnancy Symptoms
*Read with Your Kids -- It's Fun!
*Take Our Quizzes
*Play with Your Baby
TOPICS
health+
-----------
feeding+
-----------
behavior+
-----------
families+
-----------


Parents are talking about their children.
Join the discussion.



Barriers and Spermicides for Birth Control

by Marjorie Greenfield, M.D.
reviewed and revised by Marjorie Greenfield, M.D.
Barriers and spermicides are excellent methods of birth control, but they require that the couple take a lot of responsibility around the time of intercourse. Some find that this takes some of the spontaneity and pleasure out of sex, while others appreciate the protection from sexually transmitted infections that barrier methods afford. For the woman who cannot or will not use oral contraceptives, but who plans to have children some day, these forms of birth control often are the best options for her and her partner.

Couples who use barrier methods should familiarize themselves with emergency contraception, an option if the barrier method is dislodged or breaks--or if the next day, you regret not using your method consistently.

The effectiveness rates stated here are for typical use on the lower end and perfect use on the upper end. Pregnancy rates in a year would be 100 minus the effectiveness rate--so, for instance, the risk of pregnancy for condom use is 3-12 percent in a year of regular use.

Condoms--88-97 percent effective
Condoms are sheaths made of latex or animal intestine that cover the man's penis and prevent his semen from entering the woman's body. Latex condoms also provide some protection against sexually transmitted infection. In order to be effective, the condom must be put on before intercourse is begun. For the best fit, the man should already have an erection. The best latex condoms have a reservoir tip, a narrower area at the end to catch the semen. When putting on the condom, pinch the condom tip so that it is collapsed, making a place for the semen to go after ejaculation; otherwise the condom may break if too much pressure builds up inside. Just as important: The man should be sure to hold the condom at the base of the penis as he withdraws to prevent the condom from slipping off.

Condom breakage happens most commonly to men who are unfamiliar with its use. Knowing how to properly put on the condom decreases its chance of breaking. In theory, condoms have about a 3 percent failure rate. In reality, about 12 percent of women will become pregnant within one year of use. If you and your partner have condoms around for birth control, don't forget to use them. They won't do you any good sitting in your purse or buried in the back of a nightstand drawer; in such cases, the failure rate in one year jumps to nearly 80 percent.

Disadvantages:
  • Some men experience diminished sexual sensation.

  • Less spontaneity is possible.

  • A skin reaction could result if either partner is allergic to latex.

  • Effectiveness is decreased if partners fail to use the method properly.

  • Success with this method depends at least partially on the man's motivation and responsibility.
Advantages:
  • Condoms provide excellent protection from many sexually treated infections.

  • It assures the man who does not want to be a father that a method of contraception is being used.

  • Some couples enjoy the delay in the man's orgasm that goes along with slightly diminished sensation.

  • The method is reliable when used properly, especially in conjunction with a spermicide.

  • Daily pills or ongoing medical treatment aren't necessary, which can be extremely useful for people who have sex infrequently.
Female condoms--79-95 percent effective
The female condom is a thin plastic (polyurethane) sheath with a flexible ring at each end that can be bought off the shelf at the drugstore--one size fits all. The woman places the inner ring into her vagina, fitting it between her pelvic bones similarly to a diaphragm. The other ring remains outside the body, partially covering the lips of the vagina. It can be inserted anywhere from a few minutes to a few hours before intercourse.

Disadvantages:
  • Some people find the external ring or the looseness of the polyurethane sheath distasteful.

  • It's difficult for some women to insert.
Advantages:
  • The female condom acts a barrier to infection as well as a contraceptive.

  • The external coverage may provide added protection against sexually transmissible infections that are spread through skin-to-skin contact, such as herpes and genital warts (human papilloma virus).

  • It is safe for use by people who are allergic to latex.
Spermicides--79-94 percent effective
Spermicides are chemical agents that kill the sperm before it reaches the uterus. They come in the form of suppositories, foam, absorbable film, sponge, or jelly and are placed in the vagina before intercourse. Spermicides alone are not particularly good contraceptives, running the risk of up to a 20 percent failure rate in a year. They do work well, however, when combined with another method of birth control, such as condoms, diaphragm, or breastfeeding, since the effectiveness rate increases when two methods are used.

Disadvantages:
  • The chemicals or the medium (such as foam or jelly) can irritate some people.

  • Because a spermicide has to be inserted just before intercourse, it can disrupt spontaneity.

  • They taste bad.
Advantages:
  • Spermicides offer some protection from sexually transmitted infection.

  • They produce better chances of avoiding pregnancy than if no method at all were used.
The diaphragm--82-94 percent effective
The diaphragm is a dome-shaped rubber barrier that the woman places in her vagina prior to intercourse. Before insertion, the woman puts spermicidal jelly into the cup of the dome. The diaphragm holds the jelly over the cervix so that if sperm get past the barrier of the rubber, they have to swim through the spermicide in order to reach the cervix. The diaphragm must be fitted by a healthcare professional, and a specific size is then prescribed for purchase at a pharmacy. To use the diaphragm properly, the woman must be taught and must practice the insertion technique.

Disadvantages:

  • It requires a medical visit to be fitted.

  • It must be refitted after childbirth or the gain or loss of 30 pounds or more.

  • Some women are uncomfortable about putting in the diaphragm.

  • Insertion requires planning ahead for sex or interrupting sexual activity.
Advantages:
  • The diaphragm is a good choice for couples who prefer to use a barrier method but don't want to use condoms.

  • Some protection is provided against sexually transmitted infection.
The cervical cap--64-91% effective
The cervical cap, which looks like a small diaphragm, functions as a true barrier to sperm and does not require spermicide. The woman inserts it into her vagina and fits it onto her cervix, where natural suction keeps it in place.

However, while the diaphragm is difficult to learn how to use, the cervical cap is even more so, and practitioners have a tougher time learning how to fit a woman with one. It's most effective in women who have not had children. If your practitioner doesn't offer this method, check with a local family-planning clinic.

 RELATED INFORMATION
*  The Events of Ovulation
*  Birth Control


Created March 10, 2001
Reviewed and revised August 05, 2004
OUR ADVERTISERS



OUR ADVERTISERS

About Us | Contact Us | Our Partners
Privacy Policy | Ethics | Advertising Policy | Terms of Service

© Copyright 2004 The Dr. Spock Company. All Rights Reserved.

THIS SITE DOES NOT PROVIDE MEDICAL ADVICE. The information drSpock.com provides is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your health care professional if you have a specific health concern. Mention or advertisement of any product, service, or brand does not constitute endorsement, guarantee, or recommendation by The Dr. Spock Company. Please read our full Terms of Service.